10 Most Expensive Twilight Masquerade Cards (Updated: June 2025)
This post may contain affiliate links, view the disclosure for more information.
This post is all about the most expensive cards in the Twilight Masquerade set.
At what could be the halfway point of the Scarlet & Violet era, Twilight Masquerade delivers with some of the most valuable, visually stunning and playable cards we’ve seen in a long time.
Whether you’ve been collecting since Base Set or just cracked your first booster pack yesterday, there’s no denying the thrill of pulling a rare, valuable card. And Twilight Masquerade has delivered some seriously impressive hits.
In classic Scarlet & Violet fashion, Special Illustration Rares are leading the charge when it comes to value, with a few surprise cards sneaking their way into the top 10. Some of them are here for the art, some for the playability—and a few, well… nobody saw them coming.
Below is a breakdown of the top 10 most expensive cards in Twilight Masquerade as of July 2025—but not just because they’re expensive. These are the ones people are talking about, hunting, grading, and showing off in their binders for good reason.
Table of Contents
Flip each one to reveal their artwork and see why people are paying top dollar for these.
Buddy-Buddy Poffin 223/167
$18.95 🔻
$22.48 (May 2025) via Collectr
Buddy-Buddy Poffin might sound like a meme pull, but in gameplay terms, it’s actually very useful. The Hyper Rare version, though? That’s pure flex.
If you’re someone who likes to max rarity your deck, this card is right up your alley. It’s cheerful, sparkly, and just unique enough to be collectible.
B U Y O N T C G P L A Y E R →
Teal Mask Ogerpon ex 211/167
$20.52 🔻
$25.52 (May 2025) via Collectr
As the face of the set, this card was always going to be here. The design is elegant and slightly mysterious, which fits the vibe of Ogerpon perfectly. It’s a strong chase card for both collectors and competitive players.
And as beautiful as the art is, this is one of those cards that looks 10x better in person. The foil treatment and shading pop way more than most product photos can show.
B U Y O N T C G P L A Y E R →
Sinistcha ex 210/167
$22.27 ▲
$19.64 (May 2025) via Collectr
The card blends beautifully eerie artwork with a Pokémon that’s delightfully strange. Its appeal comes from its haunting aesthetic and offbeat charm—one of those sleeper cards people overlook... until they realize they need it.
Especially when paired with the unsettling narrative hinted at in Poltchageist #171/167, the two together tell a story that sticks with you.
B U Y O N T C G P L A Y E R →
Lana’s Aid 219/167
$23.88 ▲
$21.05 (May 2025) via Collectr
Lana’s Aid is one of the most relaxing, understated cards in the set — and that’s exactly why it works. While other cards scream for attention, this one invites you to take a second look. The composition, the lighting, the calm atmosphere — it’s all very intentional.
B U Y O N T C G P L A Y E R →
Kieran 218/167
$27.45 🔻
$26.13 (May 2025) via Collectr
Kieran might be one of the more divisive rivals from the Scarlet and Violet games, but there’s no debate when it comes to this card’s value.
The festival scene artwork by Teeziro is stunning, and while the card itself isn’t seeing much play, it doesn’t need to. It’s a classic example of a rare card with strong character appeal.
B U Y O N T C G P L A Y E R →
Bloodmoon Ursaluna ex 216/167
$38.26 🔻
$39.41 (May 2025) via Collectr
Bloodmoon Ursaluna ex is a literal beast. But here? It’s surrounded by Cutiefly, happy little Teddiursa, and a sun-dappled forest straight out of a storybook.
That contrast is what makes this card unforgettable. It’s a hulking, red-eyed force of nature dropped into an adorable scene. It shouldn’t work—but it absolutely does.
B U Y O N T C G P L A Y E R →
Eevee 188/167
$53.69 🔻
$64.59 (May 2025) via Collectr
It’s Eevee. Honestly, that should be enough. But just in case: it’s a bunch of Eevees. This card is packed with warmth and charm, and subtle nods to its many eeveelutions that have fans theorizing who’s who.
It’s easily one of the most feel-good cards in the entire set—a true binder darling. And that Hydreigon plush? Come on.
B U Y O N T C G P L A Y E R →
Carmine 217/167
$77.64 🔻
$79.48 (May 2025) via Collectr
Carmine’s card shows up with main character energy. Whether you’re collecting for the art, the character, or the waifu-factor (don’t lie), Carmine’s popularity was basically guaranteed from the jump.
The card ticks every box: striking art, fan-favorite character, actual playability– thanks to her discard ability.
It also doesn’t hurt that full-art female Trainers tend to perform well on the market—and Carmine’s no exception.
B U Y O N T C G P L A Y E R →
Perrin 220/167
$95.92 🔻
$99.36 (May 2025) via Collectr
Perrin isn't just valuable because of her rarity—it's the story told through the perfect pairing with her Hisuian Growlithe that seals the deal.
Collectors are going out of their way to reunite this duo in their binders, and it’s driven up the price of both cards. Because let’s face it–it would be heartbreaking to leave them separated in your binder.
B U Y O N T C G P L A Y E R →
And the most expensive card from Twilight Masquerade is…
Greninja 214/167
$288.31 🔻
$325.29 (May 2025) via Collectr
The surprise champ of Twilight Masquerade? Greninja—back on top.
The absolute king of the set. Even if you're not a Greninja fan (who hurt you?), there's no denying how clean this card looks. Greninja ex SIR hits the perfect trifecta: low pull rate, incredible art, and a built-in fanbase that spans generations. The artwork alone is reason enough to want this card — it’s dramatic, stealthy, and oozes personality.
If you pull this, please sleeve it immediately. Cry a little, then double sleeve it.
B U Y O N T C G P L A Y E R →
M O R E T W I L I G H T M A S Q U E R A D E
📋
Twilight Masquerade Visual Card List
[ PLUS Pull Rates & Chase Cards ]
TAKE A LOOK →
🧩
Twilight Masquerade Cards that Go Together
[ And Other Hidden Gems ]
TAKE A LOOK →
